Whitetail Institute Pure Attraction vs. Winter-Greens [Review]

For those looking for annual cold season food plot products from Whitetail Institute, Pure Attraction and Winter-Greens are great options, and both share a similar planting season: Fall. Nevertheless, selecting between the two can be challenging since both share many similarities.

Whitetail Institute Winter-Greens is for those after high-grade lettuce-type brassica that deer cannot resist because of its superior vegetable genetic profile. On the other hand, Whitetail Institute Pure Attraction is best for those who want both worlds because of its one-two punch advantage against the White-Greens.

Since it can all come down to one’s preference, we reviewed both products to help you choose the perfect and appropriate deer food plot for your hunting season.

A. Whitetail Institute Pure Attraction – Features and Specs

The creation of the Whitetail Institute’s Imperial Whitetail Pure Attraction is to cater to customers looking for a product that offers nutritious and abundant forage with rapid growth for the fall and winter seasons.

Aside from this, like other Whitetail Institute food plot products, Pure Attractions has proven to attract deer in both seasons: early and late. Since it is a one-two-punch product, Pure Attraction has two overlapping stages that continue to draw deer into the area during the coldest months of the year:

• Stage One: Early Season

The product’s early season nutrition and Attraction are thanks to the Whitetail Oats included in it. It is a superb forage oat that is exclusive to Whitetail Institute products.

These Whitetail Oats are high in sugar and cold tolerant, which means they can survive the harsh climate despite the grazing from deer.

In this stage, the Whitetail Oats are responsible for drawing and holding the deer into late fall as soon as they germinate, giving time for the brassica to get sweeter.

• Stage Two: Late Season

Stage two overlaps the previous setting and features Whitetail Institute forage brassicas that are popular for their lettuce-type feature, making them extremely attractive to deers.

The lettuce-type brassica stands tall in the snow and continuously attracts deer throughout the winter.

Whitetail Institute Pure Attraction has varied forage components: the Whitetail Oats, Winter Peas, WINA-210 Forage Kale, and a tiny amount of Tall Tine Turnips. Such forage component blend enables Pure Attraction to provide early and late-season Attraction and tonnage to deer.

It is also available in 26 lbs for 0.5 acres food plot and 52 lbs. for a one-acre food plot.

B. Whitetail Institute Winter-Greens – Features and Specs

Like Whitetail Institute Pure Attraction, the Winter-Greens is an annual seed blend explicitly designed for the late season: food plot and hunting.

However, Whitetail Institute Winter-Greens is mainly a lettuce-type brassica with a tiny amount of Tall Tine Turnip. It doesn’t include Whitetail Oats and winter peas forage components that Pure Attraction has.

Nevertheless, it shines on its own because it is the most irresistible brassica product that Whitetail Institute has ever tested and produced.

Winter-Greens are superior to other forage products because it has a vegetable genetic profile with over 30% protein content you cannot find on other classic brassica products.

Moreover, Whitetail Institute Winter-Greens is an easy-to-plot, fast-growing food plot product that attracts and holds deer even when other forages are gone due to cold weather and heavy grazing. You can expect it all to bloom in the winter.

Like Pure Attraction, Winter-Greens also provide great attractiveness, energy, and foliage to deer in the early and late seasons. It even stands tall under the snow and stays green.

Even two years after its first introduction on the market, Winter-Greens’ success is evidence that it’s on its way to dominating the brassica food-plot market. The product is available in three different sizes and coverage:

• 3 lbs. (0.5 acres)
• 12 lbs. (2 acres)
• 24 lbs. (4 acres/2-12 lb bags)

Whitetail Institute Pure Attraction vs. Winter-Greens Planting Dates

In using Whitetail Institute deer food plot products, it is essential to know that the planting dates may differ per area. Below is a table that helps you quickly identify when is the exact planting date in your area:

Remember to refrain from planting during hot, dry weather and stay within the recommended planting dates shown above, or you can refer to the back of the bag of food plot you purchased.

Is Whitetail Institute Pure Attraction better than Winter-Greens?

You can use both plots to attract deer during the late season, where harsh winters can destroy plants that are not strong enough to survive. However, if you want that one-two-punch advantage, you should buy the Pure Attraction instead since it offers varied forage components perfect for early and late seasons.

If we are to compare and contrast Pure Attraction and Winter-Greens, they have plenty of similarities. However, there are still quite a few differences between these two products that make one more desirable than the other.

To help you come up which product to choose, below are the following factors to look for:

• Desirability

Regarding desirability, both products are attractive to deer compared to other brands. If you compare such food plots against standard ones, deer are more into them and have continually proven irresistible for years.

For instance, Pure Attraction includes forage blends compatible with each other, allowing the food plot to reach its maximum attractiveness at two different but overlapping seasons.

On the other hand, Winter-Greens are Whitetail Institute’s most attractive brassica ever tested, making deer visit the food plot at least once a week.

Thus, the desirability of these two products is undeniably irresistible for deer who are into the nutritious food plot, helping them last throughout the cold season.

• Seed type and growth

Whitetail Institute classifies Pure Attraction and Winter-Greens as annual seed types that you can plant in the summer or fall and last through the fall or winter hunting season.

As mentioned above, Pure Attraction has four forage components: Whitetail Oats and winter peas are for the early season, while WINA-210 Forage Kale and Tall Tine Turnips are for the late season. In contrast, Winter-Greens only has two forage components: lettuce-type brassicas and Tall Tine Turnips.

Despite differences in their forage components, both seeds establish and proliferates, attracting deer to the areas as soon as they grow.

• Soil condition

Pure Attraction and Winter-Greens don’t share similar soil type requirements and conditions. The latter thrives well with well-drained to heavy soils and at least four hours of indirect or filtered sunlight.

Meanwhile, Pure Attraction is better with moderately light to medium-heavy soils—receiving a minimum of three to four hours of filtered or indirect sunlight daily.

Another thing to note is that their required soil pH level requirement is also different from each other. Pure Attraction needs a 6.0 to 7.0 optimal soil pH level, whereas Winter-Greens requires an optimal soil pH level of 6.5 to 7.0.

Remember that the seeds on a food plot will only achieve their best results if you follow the soil’s necessary pH level.

• Crop tolerance

Both products are drought and cold-resistant, so you won’t have to worry since they can stand up even during low water and cold temperatures. For example, even if rainfall in early fall is deficient, both crops can still survive and thrive.

• Digestibility and palatability

Since deer require very tender forages because they have smaller digestive systems, all brands must consider this. Luckily, both Whitetail Institute products offer very delicate forages, especially Winter-Greens, which makes them palatable to deer and easy to digest.

Moreover, the Winter-Greens get sweeter after the arrival of the first frost of fall, inviting the deer to visit the food plot over again during winter.

• Protein content

Whitetail Institute Pure Attraction and Winter-Greens offer up to 36% protein content to deer. Additionally, they turn starches in the plants into sugars providing the necessary energy for deer to last in the frigid climate.

Since both products’ designs are for early and late seasons, you can expect that they provide carbohydrate-rich foliage that helps deer survive the cold winters, wherein food is the most scarce during this time of the year. It also helps them maintain overall good health and body weight.

If you base it on Amazon star ratings, Whitetail Institute Winter-Greens has a slightly higher rating than the Whitetail Institute Pure Attraction. Nevertheless, both products are excellent choices solely dependent on one’s preference.